top of page
MONTEIRO V TEMPE UNION
Legal Insights & Opinions
CASE OVERVIEW
The Ruling Decided by the 9th District Court
In the end, after thorough consideration, the 9th District Court made the decision to dismiss Ms. Monteiro's claim regarding the alleged...
Court decisions leading up to the 9th Circuit court
"In a memorandum order filed January 2, 1997, the district court dismissed the complaint on the ground that Doe failed to state a claim...
History and background of MONTEIRO v. THE TEMPE UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT
The MONTEIRO v. THE TEMPE UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT (1998) happened in Tempe, Arizona, and is a very interesting case for a couple of...
Key Takeaways from Monteiro v Tempe Union (1998) Case:
Monteiro v Tempe Union left a lasting impact on our education system. It is discussed and analyzed in classrooms today for its unique...
Analyzing Precedents Set by Monteiro v Tempe Union (1998)
In the legal vicinity, certain court cases stand out for the precedents they set- with their ability to withstand implications and...
OPINIONS
The Group
Ultimately we unanimously agree with the ruling set by the 9th District court, We concur that the required reading of these texts was not...
Hayden Mills
While I can understand Monteiro's points, I have to ultimately agree with the decision made by the 9th district court. I agree with...
Hilary Chang
Generally speaking, I do agree with the court's ruling of upholding the school's right to assign these books. While it was not directly...
Cole Browning
I believe that the case was flawed. I understand not wanting to face racial discrimination (who does?), but Huckleberry Finn shouldn't...
Shane Bilyeu
“ The case before us does not involve an action taken by a school board that arguably abridges the First Amendment rights of its...
bottom of page